Excel or Google Sheets? How the Monthly Budget Spreadsheet Works in Both

Written by

in

The short answer

The Monthly Budget Spreadsheet is the same workbook in Excel and in Google Sheets, and the numbers agree in both. It has been tested in both, and the rollover, the quarterly review, and the paycheck-day balance come out the same. February’s rollover is $198.00 in both. February’s Available is $6,398.00 in both. The Safe to Spend on the January 31 payday reads −$56 in both, and it means the same thing in both. So the question is not which one is better. The question is which one you already have. If you have Excel, use Excel. If you do not, use Google Sheets, which is free.

The numbers are the same in both

This is the question that matters, so here is the answer first: the numbers agree. The workbook has been tested in Excel and in Google Sheets, and the sums come out the same in both.

The rollover is the same. February’s Rollover In is $198.00 in both programs, because it is the unspent money from January in the categories that roll over, and the rule is in the workbook, not in the program. February’s Available is $6,398.00 in both, because Available is Planned plus Rollover In, and the planned income is $6,200 in both.

The quarterly review is the same. The Quarterly Review tab reads the Budget, Debt Payoff, Savings Goals, and Net Worth tabs, and every number in it is a formula, so it updates itself when those tabs change. The first quarter shows the January actuals: income of $7,662, spending of $6,044.90, and $1,617.10 left over. Those numbers are the same in Excel and in Google Sheets, because the formulas are the same.

The paycheck-day balance is the same. The Paycheck tab splits each payday before you spend it, and the Safe to Spend on the January 31 payday reads −$56 in both programs. That is not an error in either program. It is the rent money, set aside to pay the rent due on February 1, and the tab shows it the same way in both.

So you do not have to worry that choosing the wrong program will give you the wrong numbers. The numbers are the workbook’s, and the workbook is the same. Choose the program you already have, and the totals will take care of themselves.

Logging on your phone

The purchase happens in the shop, in the afternoon, with the phone in your hand. The laptop is at home. That is the moment the log has to work, and it does, because the workbook opens on your phone.

In Google Sheets, open the Sheets app on your phone, open the workbook, and enter the transaction in the Transactions tab, the same way you would on the computer. In Excel, open the Excel app on your phone, and do the same. The tabs are the same, the rows are the same, and the entry takes the same minute. You do not need the laptop. You need the phone you are already holding.

Two small habits make phone logging work. First, keep the workbook open in the app, so it is one tap away instead of a search. Second, enter the purchase when it happens, or as soon after as you can, because a purchase entered in the shop is a fact, and a purchase remembered in the evening is a guess. The phone is there for the first one. The laptop is there for the second look, in the evening, when you want to see the month added up.

Your partner does not have Excel

This is the question that comes up in every household, and the answer is simple. If your partner does not have Excel, use Google Sheets. Sheets is free, and it runs in a browser, so your partner can open the same workbook on any computer, without buying anything, and enter a purchase or check the month without asking you to open your laptop.

Share the Sheets copy with your partner, and the two of you are looking at the same budget, and the same totals, and the same Dashboard. The partner who did the shopping can see what the month looks like, and the partner who did the bills can see what is left, and neither of them has to ask the other to remember it.

The workbook is built for a household, not for one person, and a household does not use one program. One person has Excel. Another does not. The workbook works in both, and the numbers agree in both, so the household can use whichever program each person already has.

Which one should you choose?

If you already have Excel, use Excel. If you do not have Excel, use Google Sheets. If you start in one and switch to the other halfway through the year, the workbook is the same, and the totals will still agree. There is no wrong choice, and there is no choice you have to make before the month starts. Open the one you have, enter the first month, and let the workbook do the adding.

You can see the Monthly Budget Spreadsheet in the shop at monthlybudget365.com. The Starter, at $12.99, is the workbook plus the Setup Guide. The Complete, at $19.99, adds the four PDFs. The Everything, at $49, adds the UK, Canada, and Australia versions. The shop charges in US dollars only.

FAQ

Will the numbers be different in Google Sheets?
No. The workbook has been tested in Excel and in Google Sheets, and the numbers agree in both. February’s rollover is $198.00 in both, February’s Available is $6,398.00 in both, and the Safe to Spend on the January 31 payday reads −$56 in both, because the rollover, the quarterly review, and the paycheck-day balance are formulas in the workbook, not features of the program.

My partner doesn’t have Excel. Can they still use it?
Yes. Use the Google Sheets copy, which is free and runs in a browser, so your partner can open the same workbook on any computer without buying anything. Share it with them, and you are both looking at the same budget and the same totals. The workbook works in Excel and in Google Sheets, and the numbers agree in both.

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *